A Case Study in GTHL Dysfunction

Guest

A Case Study in GTHL Dysfunction

Post by Guest »

The Greater Toronto Hockey League (GTHL) is known for fostering competitive youth hockey talent. However, recent events surrounding the U13AAA Mississauga Reps team highlight some glaring issues within the league.

Reports have surfaced of the Mississauga Reps holding over 20 illegal birthday skates, a blatant violation of league rules. Additionally, coaches have been accused of sending messages to players during the season, attempting to lure them onto the team, thus violating tampering regulations.

What's more concerning is the exploitation of hopeful young players and their families. With 30-40 skaters and 6 goalies attending each session, all paying $60 per skate, the coaches stand to make tens of thousands of dollars. The promise of roster selection keeps players and parents coming back, despite false assurances and unrealistic expectations.

One parent, with extensive hockey experience, shared their firsthand account of the chaotic tryout process. Their child, a mid-level AA player, attended a skate to gauge the jump to low AAA. Despite receiving vague feedback from the coach, they were continually invited back, leaving them questioning the motives behind the seemingly endless tryout cycle.

It's evident that the current system allows for profit-driven practices at the expense of player development and integrity. The GTHL's lack of intervention only perpetuates this cycle of exploitation.
Development skates are just that, they are advertised not in it only. Once you invite a player, your motives have changed.
Guest

Re: A Case Study in GTHL Dysfunction

Post by Guest »

Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 7:35 am The Greater Toronto Hockey League (GTHL) is known for fostering competitive youth hockey talent. However, recent events surrounding the U13AAA Mississauga Reps team highlight some glaring issues within the league.

Reports have surfaced of the Mississauga Reps holding over 20 illegal birthday skates, a blatant violation of league rules. Additionally, coaches have been accused of sending messages to players during the season, attempting to lure them onto the team, thus violating tampering regulations.

What's more concerning is the exploitation of hopeful young players and their families. With 30-40 skaters and 6 goalies attending each session, all paying $60 per skate, the coaches stand to make tens of thousands of dollars. The promise of roster selection keeps players and parents coming back, despite false assurances and unrealistic expectations.

One parent, with extensive hockey experience, shared their firsthand account of the chaotic tryout process. Their child, a mid-level AA player, attended a skate to gauge the jump to low AAA. Despite receiving vague feedback from the coach, they were continually invited back, leaving them questioning the motives behind the seemingly endless tryout cycle.

It's evident that the current system allows for profit-driven practices at the expense of player development and integrity. The GTHL's lack of intervention only perpetuates this cycle of exploitation.
Development skates are just that, they are advertised not in it only. Once you invite a player, your motives have changed.
Our family is new to hockey - our kid is young currently playing in Klevr. Can definitely attest to the fact that there are teams who string parents along to keep coming back for tryouts when there’s no chance for their kid to make the team.

Just wondering, what is the right way for coaches to make contact with other players then? How does a player navigate switching teams ethically? We’ve been told that teams are typically formed before tryouts, so if you don’t go to a birthday skate that your kid’s been invited to, then how does this move happen at all?
Guest

Re: A Case Study in GTHL Dysfunction

Post by Guest »

Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 7:35 am The Greater Toronto Hockey League (GTHL) is known for fostering competitive youth hockey talent. However, recent events surrounding the U13AAA Mississauga Reps team highlight some glaring issues within the league.

Reports have surfaced of the Mississauga Reps holding over 20 illegal birthday skates, a blatant violation of league rules. Additionally, coaches have been accused of sending messages to players during the season, attempting to lure them onto the team, thus violating tampering regulations.

What's more concerning is the exploitation of hopeful young players and their families. With 30-40 skaters and 6 goalies attending each session, all paying $60 per skate, the coaches stand to make tens of thousands of dollars. The promise of roster selection keeps players and parents coming back, despite false assurances and unrealistic expectations.

One parent, with extensive hockey experience, shared their firsthand account of the chaotic tryout process. Their child, a mid-level AA player, attended a skate to gauge the jump to low AAA. Despite receiving vague feedback from the coach, they were continually invited back, leaving them questioning the motives behind the seemingly endless tryout cycle.

It's evident that the current system allows for profit-driven practices at the expense of player development and integrity. The GTHL's lack of intervention only perpetuates this cycle of exploitation.
Development skates are just that, they are advertised not in it only. Once you invite a player, your motives have changed.
Reps are the worst run org in the league. All for $$$ that’s why you pay 10k plus per season… only one good team in the whole org
Guest

Re: A Case Study in GTHL Dysfunction

Post by Guest »

Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 7:35 am The Greater Toronto Hockey League (GTHL) is known for fostering competitive youth hockey talent. However, recent events surrounding the U13AAA Mississauga Reps team highlight some glaring issues within the league.

Reports have surfaced of the Mississauga Reps holding over 20 illegal birthday skates, a blatant violation of league rules. Additionally, coaches have been accused of sending messages to players during the season, attempting to lure them onto the team, thus violating tampering regulations.

What's more concerning is the exploitation of hopeful young players and their families. With 30-40 skaters and 6 goalies attending each session, all paying $60 per skate, the coaches stand to make tens of thousands of dollars. The promise of roster selection keeps players and parents coming back, despite false assurances and unrealistic expectations.

One parent, with extensive hockey experience, shared their firsthand account of the chaotic tryout process. Their child, a mid-level AA player, attended a skate to gauge the jump to low AAA. Despite receiving vague feedback from the coach, they were continually invited back, leaving them questioning the motives behind the seemingly endless tryout cycle.

It's evident that the current system allows for profit-driven practices at the expense of player development and integrity. The GTHL's lack of intervention only perpetuates this cycle of exploitation.
Development skates are just that, they are advertised not in it only. Once you invite a player, your motives have changed.
Everything said here rings true. I have been to a select few of these birthday skates and have seen first hand how they operate and the false hope they generate. Coaches give vague feedback, "I'd love to see him out again" or something to that effect. BUT THIS HAPPENS EVERYWHERE. This isn't a G problem, this is a hockey in general problem. My son's coach 2012 AAA in the O, reached out to players on other teams asking them to commit before playoffs even started (tampering much), and then hosts a slew of birthday skates under someone else's name. I think the harsh reality is, these skates are not a chance to make a team, they are a money grab. If a coach wants your kid you'll know at the end of the season (or just prior to), as that's when all the phone calls happen. Those of us in the low AAA group, we do what we can, we go to the skates, we hope, and we wait. We all know tryouts are just a formality, but what can we really do.
Guest

Re: A Case Study in GTHL Dysfunction

Post by Guest »

Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 8:02 am
Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 7:35 am The Greater Toronto Hockey League (GTHL) is known for fostering competitive youth hockey talent. However, recent events surrounding the U13AAA Mississauga Reps team highlight some glaring issues within the league.

Reports have surfaced of the Mississauga Reps holding over 20 illegal birthday skates, a blatant violation of league rules. Additionally, coaches have been accused of sending messages to players during the season, attempting to lure them onto the team, thus violating tampering regulations.

What's more concerning is the exploitation of hopeful young players and their families. With 30-40 skaters and 6 goalies attending each session, all paying $60 per skate, the coaches stand to make tens of thousands of dollars. The promise of roster selection keeps players and parents coming back, despite false assurances and unrealistic expectations.

One parent, with extensive hockey experience, shared their firsthand account of the chaotic tryout process. Their child, a mid-level AA player, attended a skate to gauge the jump to low AAA. Despite receiving vague feedback from the coach, they were continually invited back, leaving them questioning the motives behind the seemingly endless tryout cycle.

It's evident that the current system allows for profit-driven practices at the expense of player development and integrity. The GTHL's lack of intervention only perpetuates this cycle of exploitation.
Development skates are just that, they are advertised not in it only. Once you invite a player, your motives have changed.
Reps are the worst run org in the league. All for $$$ that’s why you pay 10k plus per season… only one good team in the whole org
This is becoming more and more apparent. Heard the coach is promising players spots and then de-committing.
Guest

Re: A Case Study in GTHL Dysfunction

Post by Guest »

Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 7:35 am The Greater Toronto Hockey League (GTHL) is known for fostering competitive youth hockey talent. However, recent events surrounding the U13AAA Mississauga Reps team highlight some glaring issues within the league.

Reports have surfaced of the Mississauga Reps holding over 20 illegal birthday skates, a blatant violation of league rules. Additionally, coaches have been accused of sending messages to players during the season, attempting to lure them onto the team, thus violating tampering regulations.

What's more concerning is the exploitation of hopeful young players and their families. With 30-40 skaters and 6 goalies attending each session, all paying $60 per skate, the coaches stand to make tens of thousands of dollars. The promise of roster selection keeps players and parents coming back, despite false assurances and unrealistic expectations.

One parent, with extensive hockey experience, shared their firsthand account of the chaotic tryout process. Their child, a mid-level AA player, attended a skate to gauge the jump to low AAA. Despite receiving vague feedback from the coach, they were continually invited back, leaving them questioning the motives behind the seemingly endless tryout cycle.

It's evident that the current system allows for profit-driven practices at the expense of player development and integrity. The GTHL's lack of intervention only perpetuates this cycle of exploitation.
Development skates are just that, they are advertised not in it only. Once you invite a player, your motives have changed.

This is nothing new. Every team in the league does this, to varying degrees. If it’s such a turn off then I’d suggest putting your kids in cricket.
Guest

Re: A Case Study in GTHL Dysfunction

Post by Guest »

Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 8:05 am
Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 7:35 am The Greater Toronto Hockey League (GTHL) is known for fostering competitive youth hockey talent. However, recent events surrounding the U13AAA Mississauga Reps team highlight some glaring issues within the league.

Reports have surfaced of the Mississauga Reps holding over 20 illegal birthday skates, a blatant violation of league rules. Additionally, coaches have been accused of sending messages to players during the season, attempting to lure them onto the team, thus violating tampering regulations.

What's more concerning is the exploitation of hopeful young players and their families. With 30-40 skaters and 6 goalies attending each session, all paying $60 per skate, the coaches stand to make tens of thousands of dollars. The promise of roster selection keeps players and parents coming back, despite false assurances and unrealistic expectations.

One parent, with extensive hockey experience, shared their firsthand account of the chaotic tryout process. Their child, a mid-level AA player, attended a skate to gauge the jump to low AAA. Despite receiving vague feedback from the coach, they were continually invited back, leaving them questioning the motives behind the seemingly endless tryout cycle.

It's evident that the current system allows for profit-driven practices at the expense of player development and integrity. The GTHL's lack of intervention only perpetuates this cycle of exploitation.
Development skates are just that, they are advertised not in it only. Once you invite a player, your motives have changed.

This is nothing new. Every team in the league does this, to varying degrees. If it’s such a turn off then I’d suggest putting your kids in cricket.
It's this kind of mentality that foster the dysfunction in the first place.
Guest

Re: A Case Study in GTHL Dysfunction

Post by Guest »

Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 8:59 am
Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 8:05 am
Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 7:35 am The Greater Toronto Hockey League (GTHL) is known for fostering competitive youth hockey talent. However, recent events surrounding the U13AAA Mississauga Reps team highlight some glaring issues within the league.

Reports have surfaced of the Mississauga Reps holding over 20 illegal birthday skates, a blatant violation of league rules. Additionally, coaches have been accused of sending messages to players during the season, attempting to lure them onto the team, thus violating tampering regulations.

What's more concerning is the exploitation of hopeful young players and their families. With 30-40 skaters and 6 goalies attending each session, all paying $60 per skate, the coaches stand to make tens of thousands of dollars. The promise of roster selection keeps players and parents coming back, despite false assurances and unrealistic expectations.

One parent, with extensive hockey experience, shared their firsthand account of the chaotic tryout process. Their child, a mid-level AA player, attended a skate to gauge the jump to low AAA. Despite receiving vague feedback from the coach, they were continually invited back, leaving them questioning the motives behind the seemingly endless tryout cycle.

It's evident that the current system allows for profit-driven practices at the expense of player development and integrity. The GTHL's lack of intervention only perpetuates this cycle of exploitation.
Development skates are just that, they are advertised not in it only. Once you invite a player, your motives have changed.

This is nothing new. Every team in the league does this, to varying degrees. If it’s such a turn off then I’d suggest putting your kids in cricket.
It's this kind of mentality that foster the dysfunction in the first place.
You cannot blame teams or coaches. They’re all trying to improve their group. Move tryout to August and you’d cut off a lot of this stuff. Many parents are playing the system as well. Parents commit to a team and then de commit. AA kids commit to a AA team and hope they make a AAA team. Other families posturing to see if they can get more ice time, a letter on a jersey, PP time etc. For many of the coaches it’s a full time job and holding skates is where they make money. These skates provide opportunities for some kids to skate with other kids. Parents should use them to gather information, to understand where their kid is at in the development process and whether or not they deserve to play on said team.

While I can understand someone posting this stuff, it only shows that your kid isn’t a top player and probably a bubble kid. You’re bitching because the system doesn’t work for you or someone upset you.

I don’t like the system much either but I read the original post as someone trying to cause shit. Most likely a liberal voter who believes in hand outs and equal play time.

It’s competitive sports and it’s all AAA. It’s not A or house league. It’s not about equal or same.

Do I like the system, no. But I also dislike your post. You’re a big Karen for posting it and for whining.

Find a team, culture, and coach that you like. No one is forcing you to play for the reps or forcing you to go to the skate. So really you’re just being an idiot for posting this shit.
Guest

Re: A Case Study in GTHL Dysfunction

Post by Guest »

Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 9:16 am
Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 8:59 am
Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 8:05 am
Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 7:35 am The Greater Toronto Hockey League (GTHL) is known for fostering competitive youth hockey talent. However, recent events surrounding the U13AAA Mississauga Reps team highlight some glaring issues within the league.

Reports have surfaced of the Mississauga Reps holding over 20 illegal birthday skates, a blatant violation of league rules. Additionally, coaches have been accused of sending messages to players during the season, attempting to lure them onto the team, thus violating tampering regulations.

What's more concerning is the exploitation of hopeful young players and their families. With 30-40 skaters and 6 goalies attending each session, all paying $60 per skate, the coaches stand to make tens of thousands of dollars. The promise of roster selection keeps players and parents coming back, despite false assurances and unrealistic expectations.

One parent, with extensive hockey experience, shared their firsthand account of the chaotic tryout process. Their child, a mid-level AA player, attended a skate to gauge the jump to low AAA. Despite receiving vague feedback from the coach, they were continually invited back, leaving them questioning the motives behind the seemingly endless tryout cycle.

It's evident that the current system allows for profit-driven practices at the expense of player development and integrity. The GTHL's lack of intervention only perpetuates this cycle of exploitation.
Development skates are just that, they are advertised not in it only. Once you invite a player, your motives have changed.

This is nothing new. Every team in the league does this, to varying degrees. If it’s such a turn off then I’d suggest putting your kids in cricket.
It's this kind of mentality that foster the dysfunction in the first place.
You cannot blame teams or coaches. They’re all trying to improve their group. Move tryout to August and you’d cut off a lot of this stuff. Many parents are playing the system as well. Parents commit to a team and then de commit. AA kids commit to a AA team and hope they make a AAA team. Other families posturing to see if they can get more ice time, a letter on a jersey, PP time etc. For many of the coaches it’s a full time job and holding skates is where they make money. These skates provide opportunities for some kids to skate with other kids. Parents should use them to gather information, to understand where their kid is at in the development process and whether or not they deserve to play on said team.

While I can understand someone posting this stuff, it only shows that your kid isn’t a top player and probably a bubble kid. You’re bitching because the system doesn’t work for you or someone upset you.

I don’t like the system much either but I read the original post as someone trying to cause shit. Most likely a liberal voter who believes in hand outs and equal play time.

It’s competitive sports and it’s all AAA. It’s not A or house league. It’s not about equal or same.

Do I like the system, no. But I also dislike your post. You’re a big Karen for posting it and for whining.

Find a team, culture, and coach that you like. No one is forcing you to play for the reps or forcing you to go to the skate. So really you’re just being an idiot for posting this shit.
I'm sorry but this is a parent and a coach problem. Above talks to the coach issues but if I point the finger back at you parents, if you are trying so hard to get on the reps, then you don't belong in AAA. Reps are the worst org out there filled with maybe 2 AAA kids and the rest high level AA kids. Don't force your kid into AAA unless a coach really wants them and you will know of they want them....you won't need to call them. Sorry to tell you but you as a parent are helping create this issue.
Guest

Re: A Case Study in GTHL Dysfunction

Post by Guest »

Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 9:24 am
Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 9:16 am
Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 8:59 am
Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 8:05 am
Guest wrote: Tue Apr 09, 2024 7:35 am The Greater Toronto Hockey League (GTHL) is known for fostering competitive youth hockey talent. However, recent events surrounding the U13AAA Mississauga Reps team highlight some glaring issues within the league.

Reports have surfaced of the Mississauga Reps holding over 20 illegal birthday skates, a blatant violation of league rules. Additionally, coaches have been accused of sending messages to players during the season, attempting to lure them onto the team, thus violating tampering regulations.

What's more concerning is the exploitation of hopeful young players and their families. With 30-40 skaters and 6 goalies attending each session, all paying $60 per skate, the coaches stand to make tens of thousands of dollars. The promise of roster selection keeps players and parents coming back, despite false assurances and unrealistic expectations.

One parent, with extensive hockey experience, shared their firsthand account of the chaotic tryout process. Their child, a mid-level AA player, attended a skate to gauge the jump to low AAA. Despite receiving vague feedback from the coach, they were continually invited back, leaving them questioning the motives behind the seemingly endless tryout cycle.

It's evident that the current system allows for profit-driven practices at the expense of player development and integrity. The GTHL's lack of intervention only perpetuates this cycle of exploitation.
Development skates are just that, they are advertised not in it only. Once you invite a player, your motives have changed.

This is nothing new. Every team in the league does this, to varying degrees. If it’s such a turn off then I’d suggest putting your kids in cricket.
It's this kind of mentality that foster the dysfunction in the first place.
You cannot blame teams or coaches. They’re all trying to improve their group. Move tryout to August and you’d cut off a lot of this stuff. Many parents are playing the system as well. Parents commit to a team and then de commit. AA kids commit to a AA team and hope they make a AAA team. Other families posturing to see if they can get more ice time, a letter on a jersey, PP time etc. For many of the coaches it’s a full time job and holding skates is where they make money. These skates provide opportunities for some kids to skate with other kids. Parents should use them to gather information, to understand where their kid is at in the development process and whether or not they deserve to play on said team.

While I can understand someone posting this stuff, it only shows that your kid isn’t a top player and probably a bubble kid. You’re bitching because the system doesn’t work for you or someone upset you.

I don’t like the system much either but I read the original post as someone trying to cause shit. Most likely a liberal voter who believes in hand outs and equal play time.

It’s competitive sports and it’s all AAA. It’s not A or house league. It’s not about equal or same.

Do I like the system, no. But I also dislike your post. You’re a big Karen for posting it and for whining.

Find a team, culture, and coach that you like. No one is forcing you to play for the reps or forcing you to go to the skate. So really you’re just being an idiot for posting this shit.
I'm sorry but this is a parent and a coach problem. Above talks to the coach issues but if I point the finger back at you parents, if you are trying so hard to get on the reps, then you don't belong in AAA. Reps are the worst org out there filled with maybe 2 AAA kids and the rest high level AA kids. Don't force your kid into AAA unless a coach really wants them and you will know of they want them....you won't need to call them. Sorry to tell you but you as a parent are helping create this issue.
Every coach in Ontario will have these skates. Normally there might be 1 or 2 spots and they will have 10 skates with 40 kids at $60 bucks each. It’s about $25 grand for a few weeks work. And mostly cash.
This is what coaches think about now not their team or the kids. Unfortunately the rest of society is the same these days.
Money is more important than people.
Post Reply
  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post

Return to “2004 And Younger”